So, should I pop the question to my girl or not while on Hols next week in NYC?

Holiday booked, Limo booked, romantic restaurant booked, its all good, lets have a quick whip round for public opinion if girls think she is going to say yes or no. Who can guess huh? shall I shant i?!!So, should I pop the question to my girl or not while on Hols next week in NYC?
AWWW, Yes pop the question!! The setting is perfect. Good luck xxxx Awwww how sweet
If you love each other, you should definatly ask her. Its a great little romantic trip that you have planned. I think you should go for it.So, should I pop the question to my girl or not while on Hols next week in NYC?
Sounds Wonderful! You should do it! I know she'll say YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sounds lovely. Go for it and good luck!!So, should I pop the question to my girl or not while on Hols next week in NYC?
Yes, ASK HER!!! You have all that awesome nice stuff she'll LOVE it!!
you got to ask her someday anyway...so why not during a romantic trip :)
i take it you've been seeing each other for a while and the 'L' word has already been mentioned?



In which case - i think she will say yes - i wish my hubby had put as much effort into the proposal as you are - he proposed in bed!



nevertheless, it was romantic, and he made me cry by being so sweet!
Well if she realizes what a catch you are, she will. I was proposed to with a "so do you want to get married or what?" in my dorm room. No ring, no romance! GOOD LUCK!
Seeing as how you seem to have gone to so much trouble, it would be foolish not to ask her wouldn't it?



I guess you'll stay with her even if she says "No" ?? Might put a damper on your holiday though ...
go ahead.. nothing to lose man.. good luck
well it sounds like you really love her if you did all this for her. If you've been together less than a year though you might want to wait a little longer if not it's a go. Good luck to you two :)
It sounds like you've put a lot of thought into it... that tells me you know her, love her so why wouldn't she say yes :)



Good luck and best wishes on your life together
So you're asking for butt love huh?



Its always a tough one. Its easier to get forgiveness than permission - don't ask, do...
go on, a very romantic notion!
IF YOU THINK THE BOTH OF YOU ARE READY FOR THAT COMMITMENT THEN SURE GO AHEAD HOW COULD SHE TURN YOU DOWN WITH ALL THE ROMANTIC THING YOU HAVE GOING ON FOR HER JUST TO PROPOSE .. SHE WILL SAY YES GO FOR IT
dude take her to central park on a horse and carriage and do it then doesn't get much more romantic
If you know her well you will know what she would say. I got engaged last month and it was fantastic. But we have to wait a while b4 we get married. its all about the future and what it looks like with another person, its scary if you dont know the person well enough or if you have doubts its a big descision, but if you are best friends like we are its natural to assume that theres no turning back and no hesitation. may love be stronger than any tribulation you ever find in your way!!!!
I think you should go fo it, she will love it and love you even more for making it so special. I wish you all the luck in the world
Whatchu talkin about, Willis? Where is Mr. Drummond when we need him? Where is Kimberly?
that's going to be so great...you should definetely do it if ur sure you guys both LOVE each other...she'll love it...GOOD LUCK
If you do, make sure it means something to her.



If she likes gardens, flowers, trees.....go to the botanical gardens or Central Park. If she likes theatre, try to get tickets to a play she would like. (and there are plays other than on Broadway).

Make it romantic. Stars and twinkling lights or sunshine and butterflies. It all depends on what she likes.



Good Luck.
do it - go to Central Park and do a horse %26amp; carriage ride - propose to her there - just like in the movies!
sound like a good plan.
If you're not sure then maybe you shouldn't be asking? Aw go for it...I bet she says yes!
with all that in place how can she say no. if you both love each other then ask her.
Does she love you, have you talked about your future together, if the answer is yes to both of these then you go for it, I bet she will be thrilled to bits that you have done such a romantic thing for her, don't forget to get down on one knee will you, good luck.
That sounds wonderful. Your obviously someone very much in love with her and very considerate to think of such a nice romantic setting for the occasion, she'll certainly appreciate that and of course she knows just what a wonderful person you are already, and of course if she's as much in love with you... she's bound to say yes!



Good luck
yes why not do it while in New York
I would love to come see the reception lol. You go for it luv wow if she says no ask me lol.



It sounds like your relationship is tough enough and the way you love her shows, id go for it hun u cant lose.



Goodluck and best wishes xxxxxxxxx
DO NOT ask her when your on a high in your relationship, she would obviously say yes, but what you need to know is if she will commit when you are ill/skint/drunk or homeless. Then SHE will have to think abit more of what SHE wants, a good holiday or a husband?
your gonna make me cry....i got a lump in my throat thinking bout this.



good on you for finding the love of your life, now go and enjoy the rest of your lifes together and never forget this loved up feeling you got in your heart. xx