Where to dine pre-show in new york city?

So, we will be in NYC on tuesday the 22 and I would like to know which is a better option to have an early dinner (5 o'clock) at... We have reservations for Joe Allen's, but I also heard that Kellari Taverna was good. I don't know if I will want any steak because we have reservations for another steak restaurant later in the week and I do love Greek food. Also I will be with my 15 and 16 year old daughters but they eat anything... Which place do you prefer??Where to dine pre-show in new york city?
It looks like you need reservations at both places. If your girl's like greek, I'd go to Kellari Taverna. After all, how often will you get the chance to eat there. Joe Allen's has a more typically American menu. I would check out the menus in both places and see which suits all three of you.

http://www.kellari.us/special_menus.php

http://joeallenrestaurant.com/

Hope you have a wonderful vacation in New York.Where to dine pre-show in new york city?
joe allens would be better for you and ur daughters. Also it is more enjoyable to have a late dinner so you get to see the city light up. it is truly amazingWhere to dine pre-show in new york city?
Tom's@2880 Broadway is THE Diner from Seinfeld, if anyone was/is into that? Joe Allen's is in cool area, Hell's Kitchen will be fun for the 15 and 16 adventurous types. For me, the food always tastes better when the atmosphere is happening.

italian english translation